Ketanji Brown Jackson sides with death row inmate in first opinion

Ketanji Brown Jackson sides with death row inmate in first opinion

Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, in her first opinion since taking office over the summer, objected Monday to the Supreme Court’s decision not side with an Ohio death row inmate’s claim.

Jackson, joined by fellow liberal Justice Sonia Sotomayor, said the court should have ruled for Davel Chinn, who was convicted of a 1989 murder in Dayton during a robbery. Instead, the court rejected Chinn's appeal.

Chinn's lawyers argued that prosecutors had withheld evidence that a key witness, Marvin Washington, was severely mentally disabled, with an IQ of 48. Washington had identified Chinn as the shooter.

Jackson wrote in an opinion dissenting from the court’s decision to reject Chinn’s claim that there was “no dispute” that the state had suppressed evidence that would have undermined Washington’s credibility as a witness. Under a 1963 Supreme Court ruling called Brady v. Maryland, such conduct can constitute a due process violation.

Back to blog

International Collection

Lex Pyerse has the best collection of tees, hats, and hoodies inspired by Nigeria, Mozambique, Ghana and other countries from the African diaspora. You can show your national pride while celebrating Pro-Black, Pan-African, and Black Pride and your personal uniqueness.  Each affirmation is inspired by the meanings of the colors of each nation's flag. Also, search Lex Pyerse for more clothing.